Lilly was great. The entire place was magical and what I always thought and hoped a small resort in the Keys would be. Nothing but 5's from my wife and I.

My husband and I had a wonderful stay at Atlantic Bay. The amenities were great and we enjoyed kayaking and paddle boarding. Our room was prefect as well. The only suggestion I would make is to improve the continental breakfast. There could be more options, especially considering how nice the resort is.

Stayed here for work, but such a great hotel and location. Checked in late but key was left in a safe place for me to pick up, and completed checkin the next day. Easy walk to nearby restaurants and 2mim walk to the beach. Pool onsite is small but suffices to people's needs. Plenty of parking. People very friendly. Room was large and had two double beds, a cooking area and a very clean bathroom.

This place really is a hidden gem but yet a mile away from all amenities. Come and stay for the twin king size beds if nothing else esp with a young family! The views are lovely, it’s really quiet and the airstream trailer for a sausage muffin for breakfast is perfect. We have stayed in a lot of places in the keys and this is definitely up there. Kayaks readily available and the sunsets are stunning. Ideal location half way down. We will be back!

As soon as we checked in, the front desk receptionist was extremely kind, helpful and even walked us to our condo. Kind service, 12/10 views (both daily and sunset), fish, sharks, jellyfish, hermit crabs and so much more swimming at the beautiful dock! Paddle boarded at sunset and was amazing. They have free paddle board and kayaks! BEST SUNSET IVE EVER SEEN!! Will definitely return. Love it here and never want to leave.

Great property. Clean rooms. Ours had a full size refrigerator, microwave, and stovetop. Bathrooms are mostly renovated (original sink and tub; new tile and floor) and are very nice. Spacious room with 2 king size beds and kitchen table and chairs. Very low-key vibe, and right on the water. Pool and private beach. Would stay here again (hopefully far away from the guest that smoked a cigar 24x7 which basically ruined any chance of us enjoying our patio).

We loved our stay at the Atlantic Bay Resort! We wished we had longer than our 2 night stay. The location was great, and we appreciated the peace and quiet that the resort offered, even though it was close to the highway. The rooms were cutely decorated, cozy, and had everything we needed. We hope to make it back in the future!

My wife and I just spent a week down in the Florida Keys celebrating our honeymoon and we stayed at the Atlantic Bay Resort. They were so kind to accommodate my special request of setting up the roses and wine basket that I purchased and had delivered to surprise my wife with. They had it set up in the room when we arrived. The room was beautiful, clean, and furnished with plates, silverware, and cups. The pool was also large and clean. The beach was beautiful. We saw a little shark, a few crabs, and lots of fish near the dock. The kayaks, bikes, and paddle boards were also included in the rental. They also had a few games outdoors like table tennis, Connect 4 and cornhole. They also have bug spray and sunscreen near the office. The communication with the staff was great! The breakfast selection was sufficient too. The breakfast was served out of an Airstream trailer on-site, which was cool. We highly recommend Atlantic Bay Resort and will definitely stay here again if we come back to the beautiful Florida Keys.

We absolutely enjoyed staying at this beautiful location. Our young kids enjoyed the pool and we were happy that everything was clean. The staff was friendly and accommodating. We enjoyed having a light breakfast available in the mornings.

Our family had the best time at the resort back in Feb 2025. The rooms are clean and modern. The resort itself was beautiful. Staff was friendly and accomodating. You get a nice view from the pool. We were lucky to see some dolphins swim by their private beach!! We had access to their kayaks (for FREE) which was awesome. Would 100% go back. Fun place to fly my drone. Tons of dolphins and spotted a spotted eagle ray!! No issues swimming off the beach. Tons of fish to see!!