We had an amazing stay at Coral Bay Resort in Islamorada and couldn’t be happier with our experience. From the moment we arrived, Randy made us feel completely welcome—he was an incredible host, genuinely friendly, and always willing to help with anything we needed. That personal touch really made the trip special. The resort has that classic “Old Florida” Keys vibe—laid-back, charming, and exactly what you hope for when getting away from the busy everyday pace. It was perfect for our family trip with the kids. One of the best parts was being able to fish right on the property from their back dock, which made it incredibly easy and fun for the whole family. We also enjoyed checking out some great nearby restaurants, which added even more to the experience. The property itself is beautiful and very well maintained. One of the highlights was the breathtaking sunsets right out back on the open water—absolutely unforgettable and something we looked forward to every evening. Overall, this place strikes the perfect balance between relaxation and family-friendly fun. We’ll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend to anyone looking for an authentic Florida Keys experience

We had a Sun-Thurs quiet, relaxing 4 night stay here again, we were in #5 this time w full kitchen, beds were very nice, pool, grounds superb, all the staff helpful if needed. Snorkeled right out in front/under dock and saw fish, crabs, turtles, manatees, moray eel and a shark. Old Florida vibes here.

Love this quaint little place. The manager is wonderful! Enjoyed a week of sunshine and relaxing by the pool with gorgeous sunset views from the dock. The guys went on a chartered fishing trip and we enjoyed fresh fish for dinner cooked in our room. Fun!

We enjoy staying at Coral Bay Resort for the location, people and accomodations. They have some great amenities for people who enjoy fishing, kayaking and boating. The rooms are classic, clean and efficient. The grounds have games, lounging chairs and charcoal grills throughout. With a luxurious heated pool and towels, it's easy to spend time relaxing or visiting with other guests. There are many delicious restaurants nearby and several units have kitchens. We enjoyed the convenience of cooking meals and enjoying a few meal out as well. The staff are friendly and helpful and it's all of this that keeps us going back.

Amazing place. Love it! Great pool, beach and super relaxing!

What a hidden gem! Perfect location with an amazing sunset view of the ocean. Private beach, boat dock, heated pool, patio, BBQ grill, laundry room, kayak, hammock and more. These updated beautiful pastel colored cabins at Coral Bay resort give you a cozy/quaint feeling with upscale resort amenities. ? a must stay here again and again!

What a great place to stay and enjoy. Very well maintained and clean. The whole property is beautiful. The staff top notch. Can't wait to go back some day soon. This will be my go to place when headed to the Keys

Just breathtaking. We love the whole vibe of coral Bay. It is small and cozy. We saw a MANATEE at the dock!

I’ve been going to Coral Bay for over 20 years. It’s one of the last classic Key’s places left, has such a great family feel and low key vibe. Absolute favorite spot!

Kind of a hole in the wall hidden Jim really liked the location. They got a secluded lagoon and great snorkeling right outside of the property. If you have a boat, you could dock it. We use the kitchen and cooked our own food and had great meals with great views.