I found this hidden gem as a deal on Kayak and just needed a no fuss, inexpensive roof over my head. Upon arriving the precious gentleman at the front desk, seeing I was a solo traveler, moved my room from garden to beach view. My room was large and spacious with a mini fridge, microwave, coffee pot, new TV and freezing cold air conditioner! It was heaven. They have a private beach area with Adirondack chairs, chaise lounge and dock. Kayaks and paddle boards available. But the breakfast is the piece de resistance! Homemade breakfast frittata muffins, homemade banana, blueberry, chocolate chip and cranberry muffins, yogurts, hot coffee and tea, and even cookies! It was amazing. I loved it so much I brought my husband the following weekend! As someone who often travels alone, the kindness of the staff of the Seafarer was so wonderful and refreshing. I wish more locally owned hotels still existed.

We had such an amazing stay. Everyone was friendly and the gather with random strangers at breakfast made the entire stay that much more enjoyable. Kayaks are free and having a private beach with was an added bonus. Awesome stay if you have an electric vehicle as they have 2 Tesla chargers that can be used on sight.

My family of 4 first time visiting the keys!! Very relaxing and quiet. My kids enjoyed the water, sand, and hammocks there. Rooms were perfect size for us and clean!! We stayed at the bonefish cottage. The lady that makes the delicious muffins for breakfast was so nice to us when we were leaving. The guy named Guy called us to make sure we were having a a safe drive to the restore since we booked and paid for it over the phone!! When we come back we will definitely be staying here. Parking lot little small but that ok. We had a huge truck. Lots of fun stuff to do off the highway. Can’t wait to go back.

My wife and I really enjoyed our stay at this little gem and enjoyed the sunsets. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The beach ?? is very well kept with plenty of umbrellas and tables and chairs. We booked the room because of the positive reviews. By the way the breakfast was also good ? We learned how to make fritatas. We would book here agaln.

I booked our stay based on reviews/ratings - found out not a lot of places actually have a sandy shoreline like Seafarer does; often its just rocks and docks. So that was an immediate win. The beach area is smaller and intimate, shared by all guests, but being able to get in the water easily was so nice. We saw a manatee at sunset our first night here! We also enjoyed the many different seating options: chairs and tables with umbrellas, sun chairs, a little table outside our cottage (unit 6) and a picnic table on the dock...it was so great to have choices. As a former vacation property manager and head of housekeeping, cleanliness standards in our unit get a solid approval. Clean sheets, clean extra blankets, and a freshly laundered bedspread. Clean towels. Clean floors, clean shower toilet and sink. Kitchen area and fridge also in great shape. Nothing smelled bad, nothing sticky. And they did a towel/trash refresh for us during a 2 night stay; we really appreciated that. Units are vintage with modern elements, and they did a good job sanitizing for our stay. Guest laundry on site, water/pop machine, beach towels in the office.. SUPER close to LOTS of food, gas, shopping spots. Beach houses are durably constructed so wifi doesnt penetrate our unit well, but who CARES when you're in the keys!! Cold AC, firm bed, great shower, ample kitchenette; nice light breakfast offerings- frittatas were yummy. Would stay again. Thank you, Seafarer staff.??

This place is a gem! I loved the old Florida feel with modern amenities. The rooms are nice and clean. The outside breakfast area is adorable with a café style area to hang out with other guests. The food is delicious! ? Looked forward to the muffins and frittattas every morning. Having your own private beach was wonderful! I spent most of my week there. Relaxing and beautiful. The staff is friendly and helpful with anything you need. Will definitely return!

Overall experience was great. Had trouble getting our rental car after flying into Miami. We said we'd be a little late and arrive after check-in hours and they were able to accommodate us no problem. We love these little sea side kind of motels and cottages and the Seafarer didn't disappoint. Quaint clean rooms with the necessities. View was great. Breakfast was good too. Not an all you can eat buffet, but enough to get the day started. My wife and I enjoyed our stay and would book again if we find out way back to the keys.

This place is a hidden gem. The rooms are extremely clean, management and staff are extremely courteous. The beach area is absolutely beautiful. The breakfast frittata and muffins are home made and delicious; Definitely staying here again.

Everything about this place is absolutely amazing. Robert at the front desk was extremely nice and helpful. The rooms have the charm of the old Florida vibe and feel like you traveled back to the 60’s. A very good thing in my opinion! The rooms are clean and cozy. The private beach is absolutely breathtaking and never too crowded. All the guest are so friendly. This place is also not the teenage loud party experience. It is more of quiet, calming, “forget about your problems” experience that I needed very badly. Free kayaking was a major bonus! We will be back. Thank you Seafarer 10/10 ?

What a gem! Would totally recommend and would love to stay again! Great location, room and atmosphere. Loved having home made breakfast and coffee on the beach everyday. Staff is amazing and it's a great spot for beach sunsets. Thank you for having us! - Thomas family ????