We drove up from Miami with our boat for a fishing trip with my son and friend. The hotel was very clean and maintained but the real stars were the staff, Riley and Alfie. They were very accommodating and extremely nice and catered to our needs and made the experience truly pleasant. The boat slip was ok but could have been better maintained and the room was a little small for being a seaside villa. The boat marina was fine and suited our needs. We will definitely be back when we visit again.

We chose this property based on the photos, amenities, and positive reviews, but unfortunately our experience was very different. The rooms were simple but clean, and Alfie was consistently friendly, welcoming, and helpful throughout our stay. That said, the advertised amenities did not live up to expectations. The property advertises complimentary bikes, paddleboards, kayaks, and outdoor games. However, for a 70-room property, there were only two bikes available, which wasn’t practical for our family of four. Even worse, there were only two paddleboards and two kayaks—and neither was usable. One paddleboard was literally falling apart, and the paddles were broken, so the whole setup was basically useless. The ping pong table was broken too, with no paddles available anyway. Paying a daily resort fee for amenities that are broken, unavailable, or barely functional is honestly ridiculous. The continental breakfast was also much more limited than expected, consisting mainly of toast, bagels, cereal, and a few basic items. The biggest issue occurred when we returned after spending the day on the water and discovered there was no running water anywhere on the property due to a broken pipe. I completely understand that emergencies like this happen and are outside of the hotel’s control. My disappointment wasn’t the broken pipe—it was the lack of communication from management. There was no proactive update, no acknowledgment of the inconvenience, and no offer of assistance or accommodations. We ultimately decided to check out early and leave because there was no indication of when the issue would be resolved. Overall, while the rooms were clean and one staff member went above and beyond, the property did not match the online description, and the amenities that supposedly justified the resort fee were largely unusable. I hope management addresses these issues and improves communication with guests during unexpected situations.

Perfect location for anything you would want to do in Islamorada. Great views from our unit 323. Really enjoyed our stay. The bed was ok. The couch was a little hard but sufficient. Only major Issue was with roaches in kitchen and bath area. Came in one night from a local bar with pizza for dinner, set it on the kitchen counter and went down and visited with local guests for about an hour. Returned to find the roaches had found their way into our pizza box. Needless to say no dinner for the night. Emailed and text the office with pics of the bugs, only asking for a refund of $17.19 for dinner we were unable to eat. I was contacted, but was never followed up with. Customer satisfaction was not a priority. Sometimes it does not pay to be nice or discreet. Lesson learned. When you pay good money, you definitely expect not to have bugs in your unit.

I stayed here for a week with a few friends in early March. The hotel is a basic, no-frills place - the grounds are nice and the rooms are comfortable, but there's nothing amazing to write home about. The room had a comfortable bed, decent air conditioning and plenty of hot water with good water pressure in a big shower. The mini-fridge was nice to keep drinks cold and there was a Keurig and microwave on the counter. My room had literal dust bunnies clinging to the wall. Room cleaning is by request and needs 24 hours notice, but there should still be a thorough cleaning between guests. It's clear that this just wasn't the case. The location was good for us - we were scuba diving with a shop less than a mile down the road. And the service road the hotel was on was great for getting the daily runs done without having to worry about a ton of traffic. The parking lot got crowded at times, but we always found a spot no matter what time we got back. We didn't use the pool, but the speakers stayed on all night and could be heard in the closer rooms. The beach seemed nice but there was no ocean access. The fire pit area was nice and could be fun with a larger group. I didn't eat at the food truck, but the menu looked (and smelled) great. My limited interactions with the staff were great - everyone was very friendly. The breakfast options were sparse and really best for just a quick snack before getting on the road. They were nice enough to extend a First Responder Discount. So for the price, I'd likely stay here again - but request a deep cleaning upon arrival.

This place is a great getaway in the keys, without having to drive all the way down to Key West. It is definitely a better value play than some of the really expensive places to stay. If you or someone in your family loves fishing, they can fish right off the back. There is a dock there that has a nice set up. There is an area to play cornhole, build with blocks and sit by a fire pit or in the hammock. My son caught dozens of fish on the property and we also saw a manatee with its baby calf right next to the dock. There is a pool as well but I did not use it. I stayed in a standard two king room. There was plenty of room to spread out with a family of four. It is peaceful, quiet, and relaxing. There are also some good restaurants nearby. We did have some minor issues the first night, But the staff worked to make sure everything was taken care of right away. The manager, Andres is also very helpful and accommodating.

Excellent place to stay right on the water with facilities to enjoy kayaking etc. Our rom was spacious and clean with a nice balcony looking out at the ocean. The breakfast was included and simple and adequate. A food truck on site served delicious thai food. The staff were very friendly. Though it was on Route 1, our room was quiet and we heard no noise. There was an osprey nest, almost in front of the hotel with quiet places to walk around. Do remember to visit the Turtle hospital and Seven mile bridge, when you are here.

An amazing place and fantastic staff, and Thomas was very friendlyand attentive . My wife and I had a wonderful gateway and definitely will come back to Fisher Inn Resort. We brought our dinghy boat and used the ramp/marina facility. That was a plus ! Regards Rafael & Aisha

Lovely renovation.. room was beautiful but too pricey for motel like place. For a bit more you can stay at a luxury resort with a true beach view, restaurants, bars, nicer pool(s) and not mangroves in front of your room off a fishing walkway.. Staff was extemely friendly and efficient especially front desk. Clean, clean, clean.. very well kept. Would recommend if you want to pay the high price and stay in motel like place. Access to beach is nice, great chairs and tiki shade cabanas and good fishing right out front.

Everything was fantastic. The rooms were very clean and smelled great. The outside was tidy and taken care of. The lobby staff were polite and thorough. Our AC was the only issue. It wouldn't keep up, and we would all wake up sweating every night. It was also the coldest day of the year! The mini-splits were still working double time.

Well. I just change my review. Worst place ever. I have 6 pictures of bed bugs or (some type of mite). I've been itching for days & thought I was allergic. Come to find out ot was bugs. I tried to work out something out with the front desk & worse customer service ever. Took calls while speaking with her Ignored me Didn't call me for 3 hrs- went back down & acted surprised by the entire converstion conversation as if I had never been down to speak to her. Did nothing since there's no other available rooms here. Rated another fifteen minutes, forced her to call a manager...who isn't even on site. Actual horrible place. Do not ever stay here.