The staff there is wonderful and treated us like family. Bridget and Chris at the concierge desk there were great they really went above and beyond accommodate the whole family. Also the restaurant managers Jerry and Carlos along with two servers Dan and Kate were wonderful all weekend which made our dining experiences very pleasurable. As soon as we stepped foot off the ferry, we were greeted by Jaz he made you feel so welcome and was so helpful in getting us to the right places. The staff and the whole island experience was great. Will return soon.

This is a one of a kind experience. On your own island when you are a five minute ferry ride away from Key West. Everything is first rate. The food, service, people, and experience are all excellent. So worth doing for a special experience.

This is more than just a beautiful place to stay — it feels connected to the spirit of Key West in a very special way. The peaceful island setting, the cottages, the sunsets, and the quiet atmosphere make it feel like a place you remember long after you leave. For us, it has a personal connection to Key West: calm, warm, relaxed, and full of that unique island feeling. A truly special place that feels private, peaceful, and unforgettable.

Great property and overall an excellent experience with Sunset Key Cottages. Beautiful accommodations, relaxing atmosphere, and top-notch service throughout the stay. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a luxury getaway in Key West.

Our stay at the cottage was absolutely wonderful from start to finish. The property itself was beautiful, peaceful, and well-maintained. Perfect for a relaxing getaway. Every detail felt thoughtfully prepared, making it easy to settle in and truly enjoy the experience. Exceptional service! Thank you, Mr. Neil and crew.

This place was incredible and the reviews don’t do it justice. The staff was so kind and knowledgeable. The entire island and set up is gorgeous. The ferry ride is a fun feature as well that makes it feel extra fun and exclusive. You won’t be disappointed.

Well headed over to Sunset key cottages to go to the restaurant there latitudes always go in for lunch you might want to go a little earlier or a little late particularly if you want to have a seating outside it fills up around noon so make your reservation well in advance. Very nice water taxi takes you over and back a wonderful experience and delicious food and don't let me forget about the wonderful Associates who are so friendly

Staying with my close friends Steve and Michelle, this has been one of the best vacations I've had. Key West is fun, but having the ability to escape to this oasis is much more worth it. Staff here are all extremely friendly. I hope to be back many times in the future.

Another fabulous day at Sunset Key Cottages! Beautiful property located on a secluded island offering a large, peaceful beach area. Caesar is the best when it comes to drinks by the beach, towel service and even bringing over a raft to float on. I can’t say enough about the food, which is consistently delicious. Our server Eva was fantastic. The pool is stunning and Thomas the pool bartender is the best. He is so kind and his drinks are the best- try the Key Lime Colada with a graham cracker rim! We love our time at Sunset Key and thank you to Chris who runs everything so well- you won’t find a better property or better service anywhere else. Well done, Chris!

This is not a family resort in our opinion. For the price you can take your family somewhere else. They have a small pool. The little private beach they have has rocks and seaweed. Careful when closing the doors in the cottages. The door jams are positioned weird. You can easily jam your hand/fingers when closing the doors. The private beach doesn't look like the pictures on their website. Overall they only have the small pool and the small private beach.